Articles | Volume 4, issue 2
https://doi.org/10.5194/ar-4-589-2026
© Author(s) 2026. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Isomer-resolved online analysis of organic aerosols using ion mobility mass spectrometry
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 19 Nov 2026)
- Supplement to the final revised paper
- Preprint (discussion started on 10 Apr 2026)
- Supplement to the preprint
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
- RC1: 'Comment on ar-2026-13', Kangwei Li, 19 May 2026
- RC2: 'Comment on ar-2026-13', Anonymous Referee #2, 25 May 2026
- AC1: 'Comment on ar-2026-13', Andre Schaum, 19 Jun 2026
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
AR by Andre Schaum on behalf of the Authors (22 Jun 2026)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Publish subject to technical corrections (03 Jul 2026) by Andreas Held
AR by Andre Schaum on behalf of the Authors (01 Nov 2026)
Manuscript
This manuscript develops a new technique called VIA-CI-IMS-TOF for online and isomer-resolved aerosol chemical analysis. The authors evaluated the performance of this instrumentation using 10 different carboxylic acids over a wide range of temperature. They further applied this technique into a chamber experiment with ozonolysis of a-pinene, which is able to prove its ability for identifying some isomers at real time. SOA are complicated mixture with diverse composition and structures. IMS is a promising technique coupling with MS for real-time isomer-resolved measurement. This technique is expected to deepen our molecular-level characterization and understanding of SOA. I strongly recommend its publication after addressing the below comments
Major comments
1. I never work with VIA and CI-IMS-TOF. Coupling both is a smart idea and the key aspect of this study. Since VIA and CI-IMS-TOF are both commercially available, I wonder whether this combination (or so-called coupling) could be readily used/achieved straightforward if both are available? What is the key challenge of achieving such combination?
2. I also wonder whether it is possible to achieve real-time and isomer-resolved gas-phase and particle-phase analysis simultaneously during one single chamber experiment, e.g. by switching two lines of charcoal denuder and HEPA particle filter in front of VIA?
3. Line 145-150 The authors mentioned that standards are vaporized into the chamber and then condensing onto seed particle, as their first sets of chamber expts. What type of seed particles is used during these expts? Is there any specific reason that standards are prepared in methanol not water? Also, I am a bit confused with the later text that some standards were pipetted onto a PTFE filter that placed between VIA and AIM (CI-IMS-TOF), but using heated chamber air to evaporate analytes from PTFE filter. It seems these are two methods of bringing standards into the instrument. Why two methods are required? Are they targeting for different standards? Can the authors explain why not directly injecting these standards by nebulizing the standard solution into organic particles following a dryer before entering into VIA-CI-IMS-TOF?
4. Fig. 1 shows that these standards are nicely separated at different drift time. Can drift time information be used to infer to some chemical properties? e.g. HPLC retention time is an indicator of polarity. Also, why only using carboxylic acids as standards in the entire study? Could this technique apply for other non-carboxylic acid compounds such as esters, peroxides, carbonyls, etc?
5. For this VIA-CI-IMS-TOF technique, I wonder whether it is possible to demonstrate its quantification ability by varying the concentration of standards, and providing quantification capability information such as detection limit (e.g. LOD, LOQ) and linear range like traditional chemical analysis?
6. For chamber expt as shown in Fig. 3 and Fig. 5, many isomer peaks are not baseline separated. Is there any hope that this issue could be further improved in IMS settings?
7. I also wonder how did the authors fit those not-well-resolved peaks, e.g. how the software treating the data automatically and identifying those isomer peaks in IMS for each m/z? Currently only a few formulas with standards are shown for chamber SOA, but I assume there should be many isomer peaks for many other compounds. I wonder how many isomers are found for other formulas, e.g. dimers and other compounds? The most simple way is to show a typical molecular fingerprint like HPLC-HRMS using rt vs. m/z, therefore I am curious if the authors could provide a scatter plot and/or excel sheet for chamber a-pinene SOA, by showing drift time vs. m/z while dots were coloured by peak area/intensity? This plot could be used in the maintext to strengthen the current method for a broader identification of isomer-resolved peaks
8. It seems there are two identical chamber SOA expts but switching between Br- and I- reagent, am I right? For Fig. 5, I guess Br- and I- give two different drift tube time for each standard. Can the authors label the name of the corresponding isomer peak for each standard? Indeed, Br- and I- reagent ions could provide more detailed chemical information, but it might also make the data analysis and interpretation even more complicated, and I think the current result is still very preliminary.
9. I could not find the detailed information that how the drift time calibration was performed in sec 3.1. If I understand correctly, this drift time calibration is only necessary for VIA temperature ramping experiment. It seems VIA was operated at a fixed temperature of 200 C for chamber SOA expts. Is there any specific reason of choosing this fixed temperature that is different than ramping 30-170 C used for standards? By the way, would VIA operating at multiple temperature give more information?
Minor comments
Line133 “peak s” → “peaks”
For Fig. 2, terpenylic acid formula should be C8H12O4
For the data showing in Fig. 3 and Fig. 5, what is the IMS collected time during the chamber SOA expt? Are they referring to the averaged ~1 minute near the end of the experiment?